Q Magazine (9/95, p.138) - 4 Stars - Excellent - "...Remarkably, not just for fans..."
New Musical Express (7/29/95, p.48) - 7 (out of 10) - "...one of the better bands to emerge from the phenomenon that was grunge. Superchunk never hated themselves, never wanted to die, but as they moved from the power pop of their early releases into the guilt-veined '90s, they awkwardly, well, matured..."
Alternative Press (10/95, p.78) - "...This compilation will most likely appease those hungry for product while making no converts, and that's fine..."